Thanksgiving & Harvest Hymns of Gratitude: Choral & Orchestral Scores (Elgar, Vaughan Williams, Bach & Rutter) — Edition Comparison & Buying Guide
Anchor editions include Edward Elgar: With Proud Thanksgiving (Novello & Co, Cat. Z122826, 181 pp.); Ralph Vaughan Williams: A Song of Thanksgiving (Oxford University Press, Cat. 9780193394575, 213 pp.); and Johann Sebastian Bach: Cantata “Nun danket alle Gott”, BWV 192 (Breitkopf & Härtel, Cat. 9790004205174, 164 pp.), alongside companion solo, chamber, choral, and orchestral sets.

1. Featured Urtext & Performance Editions — Which Urtext Edition Should You Choose?
1. Edward Elgar: With Proud Thanksgiving (Novello & Co)
Editorial Note:Authorized edition issued by Novello & Co (Cat. Z122826), comprising 181 total pages across 36 parts.
2. Ralph Vaughan Williams: A Song of Thanksgiving (Oxford University Press)
Editorial Note:Authorized edition issued by Oxford University Press (Cat. 9780193394575), comprising 213 total pages across 23 parts.
3. Johann Sebastian Bach: Cantata “Nun danket alle Gott”, BWV 192 (Breitkopf & Härtel)
Editorial Note:Authorized edition issued by Breitkopf & Härtel (Cat. 9790004205174), comprising 164 total pages across 12 parts.
2. Companion Offprints & Specialist Volumes
Individual works, alternative editorial lineages, and chamber, choral, or orchestral sets indexed in this collection:
Mack Wilberg: Praise to the Lord, the Almighty
Verified Oxford University Press edition (Cat. 9780193863842), 71 pp.
John Rutter: Now thank we all our God
Verified Oxford University Press edition (Cat. 9780193673571), 69 pp.
Bob Chilcott: The Song of Harvest
Verified Oxford University Press edition (Cat. 9780193706637), 47 pp.
Henry Purcell: O Give Thanks, Z 33
Verified Novello & Co edition (Cat. Z122994), 39 pp.
3. Additional Indexed Holdings & Cross-References
Additional Verified Catalog Holdings: Johann Sebastian Bach: Cantata BWV 137: 'Lobe den Herren, den mächtigen König der Ehren' (Breitkopf & Härtel, 9790004204887, 137 pp.); Mack Wilberg: Praise to the Lord, the Almighty (Oxford University Press, 9780193863859, 71 pp.); John Rutter: For the Beauty of the Earth (Oxford University Press, 9780193415188, 63 pp.); Mack Wilberg: Come, Ye Thankful People, Come (Oxford University Press, 9780193869110, 61 pp.); Bob Chilcott: Now thank we all our God (Oxford University Press, 9780193442559, 52 pp.); Ralph Vaughan Williams: A Song of Thanksgiving (Oxford University Press, 9780193394568, 39 pp.); John Rutter: For the beauty of the earth (Oxford University Press, 9780193540620, 36 pp.); Mack Wilberg: For the Beauty of the Earth (Oxford University Press, 9780193388840, 35 pp.); Darius Milhaud: Festal Voluntaries: Harvest (Novello & Co, NOV010100, 32 pp.); Ralph Vaughan Williams: A Song of Thanksgiving (Oxford University Press, 9780193707825, 29 pp.); Mack Wilberg: Praise to the Lord, the Almighty (Oxford University Press, 9780193862982, 27 pp.); Mack Wilberg: Praise to the Lord, the Almighty (Oxford University Press, 9780193862999, 27 pp.).
Supplementary Publisher Catalog Numbers: Additional editions indexed in this collection include catalog references WH29307, 9780193703995, Z122986, NOV460018, 9780193543072, 9780193542938, NOV956791, AL28522, 9780193542921, 9780193525535, 9780193541665, 9780193525054. Open any score card below to inspect full part-by-part page counts and edition details.